The following Saint Joseph's student-athletes received postseason individual awards or All-America honors in 2016:
• DeAndre' Bembry (Men's Basketball) – Atlantic 10 / Big 5 Player of the Year
• Josh Clark (Men's Cross Country) – Atlantic 10 Rookie of the Year
• Charlie Concannon (Baseball) – Louisville Slugger Freshman All-America
• Emily Gingrich (Women's Soccer) – Atlantic 10 Midfielder of the Year
• T.J. Jones (Men's Lacrosse) – NEC Defensive Player of the Year
• Rebecca Lane (Women's Lacrosse) – Atlantic 10 Rookie of the Year
• Isaiah Miles (Men's Basketball) – Atlantic 10 / Big 5 Most Improved Player
• Dakota Mills (Women's Soccer) – ECAC / Atlantic 10 Offensive Player of the Year
• Mike Rastivo (Men's Lacrosse) – NEC Player of the Year; NEC Offensive Player of the Year; USILA Honorable Mention All-America
• Pepa Serrano (Field Hockey) – Atlantic 10 Rookie of the Year
• Deon Stafford, Jr. (Baseball) – ECAC / Atlantic 10 / Philadelphia Big 5 Baseball Player of the Year; Louisville Slugger Third Team All-America
• Pat Swanick (Men's Lacrosse) – Senior CLASS Award Second Team All-America
• Gabrielle Vagnozzi (Women's Soccer) – Atlantic 10 Rookie of the Year
• Anna Willocks (Field Hockey) – Atlantic 10 Offensive Player of the Year; Philadelphia inquirer Academic All-Area Field Hockey Performer of the Year; NFHCA Second Team All-America
• Chelsea Woods (Women's Basketball) – Big 5 Most Improved Player